| 1880 | |
| NSW Wanderers | |
| Kings School | |
| Arcadians | |
| 1881 | |
| Coreen College | |
| 1885 | |
| Granville | |
| Canterbury | |
| Parramatta | |
| Caledonians | |
| Embroys | |
| Katoomba | |
| Friendly Society of Parramatta | |
| Pyrmont Rangers | |
| Pyrmont Rovers | |
| Pyrmont Rosebuds | |
| Young Mens Field Association | |
| 1886 | |
| Raymond | |
| 1888 | |
| North Illawarra | |
| Joadja (Southern Cross) | |
| 1889 | |
| Woonona | |
| Lithfow Rangers | |
| Parkgrove Pilgrims | |
| Illawarra Rovers | |
| 1890 | |
| Mt Victoria | |
| Pyrmont Swifts | |
| Helensburgh Rovers | |
| Balgownie | |
| 1891 | |
| Balmain | |
| Corrimal | |
| Burwood Forresters | |
| 1892 | |
| Rosehill | |
| 1893 | |
| Pyrmont Thistles | |
| Auburn Wanderers | |
| Pyrmont Carleton | |
| Sydney Thistles | |
| True Blue | |
| 1894 | |
| Scottish Rifles | |
| Broughton Creek | |
| 1895 | |
| Corinthians | |
| Balmain Endeavour | |
| Balmain Fusiliers | |
| Balmain Rovers | |
| Granville Pirates | |
| Pyrmont Waratahs | |
| Balmain Native Rose |