Discontinued after 2004

written by John Punshon

Season	Winner
2004	Green Gully Cavaliers
2003	Not played
2002	Not played
2001	Not played
2000	Not played
1999	Not played
1998	Not played
1997	Not played
1996	Melbourne Knights
1995	South Melbourne
1994	Morwell Falcons
1993	South Melbourne
1992	Preston
1991	South Melbourne Hellas
1990	Melbourne Croatia
1989	South Melbourne Hellas
1988	South Melbourne Hellas
1987	Brunswick United Juventus
1986	Green Gully
1985	Melbourne Croatia
1984	Fawkner
1983	Melbourne Croatia
1982	Green Gully
1981	Green Gully
1980	Essendon
1979	Essendon
1978	George Cross
1977	Juventus
1976	Footscray JUST
1975	South Melbourne Hellas
1974	South Melbourne Hellas
1973	Hakoah St.Kilda
1972	Juventus
1971	Juventus
1970	Juventus
1969	Croatia
1968	Croatia
1967	Port Melbourne Slavia
1966	Hakoah
1965	Slavia
1964	Slavia
1963	Footscray JUST
1962	George Cross
1961	Polonia
1960	Brunswick Juventus
1959	George Cross
1958	Ringwood Wilhelmina
1957	Moreland
1956	Hakoah
1955	Hakoah
1954	Hakoah
1953	Hakoah
1952	Brighton
1951	J.U.S.T.
1950	Moreland
1949	Park Rangers
1948	Park Rangers
1947	South Yarra
1946	Prahran
1945	Moreland-Hakoah
1944	Brighton
1943	Brighton
1942	Prahran
1941	Moreland
1940	Imperial Chemical Industries
1939	Imperial Chemical Industries (formerly Nobels)
1938	Nobels
1937	Brighton
1936	Royal Caledonians
1935	Hakoah
1934	Royal Caledonians
1933	Brighton
1932	Footscray Thistle
1931	Wonthaggi Magpies
1930	Footscray Thistle
1929	Footscary Thistle
1928	Navy
1927	Footscray Thistle
1926	Navy
1925	Melbourne Thistle
1924	Navy
1923	St.Kilda
1922	Albert Park
1921	Northumberland and Durham
1920	Finalists: Albert Park & Northumberland and Durham (game abandoned)
1919	Footscray Thistle
1918	No competition due to World War 1
1917	No competition due to World War 1
1916	No competition due to World War 1
1915	Melbourne Thistle
1914	Melbourne Thistle
1913	Yarraville (formerly Williamstown)
1912	Williamstown
1911	St Kilda
1910	Carlton United
1909	Carlton United