1934 Dockerty Cup Results

written by John Punshon
Sources: The Argus, The Sun


Line-ups on this page are the selected teams published in the newspapers on Saturday mornings.
Some clubs named more than eleven players without specifying the intended starting line-up.

Home Team v Away Team
Round One
Saturday, May 12, 1934. Referee: D Leese.
Box Hill
R Brown, A Willis, Jack Giles, Calder, Johnson, Miller, E Young, Jim Giles, Paton, Naismith.
0 - 1 South Melbourne
Fenn, A Kego, W Gow, J Sinclair, W Muir, Wilson, Reid, J Kego, F O'Brien, P O'Brien, Smith. Res: J Cramond, Sketcher.
Goal: F O'Brien
Saturday, May 12, 1934. Referee: J Fraser.
Coburg
Campbell, Mason, D Spiers, Watt, Vost, D Bruce, Sparks, Burr, Warman, Tennant, Fraser.
Goal: Warman
1 - 2 St Kilda
Shepherd, Pollock, Bull, J Patterson, Herbert, W Huck, Barron, Dick, Dawson, Nixon, Grant. Res: Phillips, Soames, Arnold, Munday.
Goals: Dick x 2
Saturday, May 12, 1934. Referee: Harold Slight.
Collingwood
Spooner, France, Whittaker, Muzzell, Hubbard, J Conlon, Stroud, A Comery, R Gallie, Catterall, Mee. Res: Macklin.
0 - 4 South Yarra
Lacey, Harris, Ziebell, Not known, Peter McCluskey, Addie, Stevenson, Spetch, J Baxter, Duff, Bailey. Res: Forrester, Lott, Randall.
Goals: Baxter x 2, Duff, Stevenson
Saturday, May 12, 1934. Williamstown Road, Yarraville. Referee: R Hamilton.
Footscray Thistle
W Morton, Hughes, Fitzgerald, J Wilson, W Wilson, Campbell, J Morton, Pearson, Cunningham, O'Brien, R Gordon. Res: Brydson, G McDonald, Fulton.
Goals: J Wilson x 2
2 - 2 Sunshine
McPherson or Finn, Shaw, Haxby, Owens, Haxby, Taylor, Campbell, Taylor, Clayton, Douglas, Bradley. Res: Haxby, Plekin, Fleming, James.
Goals: J Campbell, Pickett
Saturday, May 12, 1934. Middle Park. Referee: Tommy Burns.
Melbourne Thistle
McKelvey, McDonald, Drennan, Briggs, Kelly, Knight, Crew, Treadwell, Craig, Hughes, Paulsen.
Goals: Paulsen x 2, Kelly, Hughes
4 - 1 Geelong United
Nutter, Sandy Hammond, Buckley, Ogg, Cameron, Blacklock, Whittemore, White, Blundell, Durward, A Beveridge. Res: W Beveridge, Massey, McArthur.
Goal: Durward
Saturday, May 12, 1934. Referee: L Russell.
Moreland
Parker, Gillon, McFarlane, Hawley, Jones, Friend, Johnstone, Smillie, Semple, Cummins, Old, Douglas, Mackie.
Goals: Semple, Friend, Cummins
3 - 2 Brown Coal Mine United

Goals: Carmichael, Pearless
Saturday, May 12, 1934. Flinders Naval Depot, Crib Point. Referee: J Anderson.
Flinders Naval Depot

Goals: Samways x 2, Hamon x 2, McKay, Own goal
6 - 1 Morwell

Goal: Bryce
Saturday, May 12, 1934. Referee: J Parker.
Preston
Croot, Smith, Macauley, Anstee, Lyons, Colgrave, Tom McCluskey, Fraser, Cook, Knowles, Fairweather. Res: Hamilton.
Goals: Cook, McCluskey
2 - 1 Brighton
Barnes, Evans, D Smith, Cliffe, Fred Ursell, Hector Howie, S Humphrey, H Campbell, Not Known, McGirr, Duncan McDougall. Res: Hambly.
Goal: McGirr
Saturday, May 12, 1934. Middle Park. Referee: Tom Lawrence.
Royal Caledonians
Bob Morgan, George Weir, H Beats, Andy Mayne, S Weir, Stewart, Peter Young, B Gray, J Lyons, Johnstone, Robb. Res: R Gray.
Goals: Mayne x 3, Johnstone
4 - 0 Pascoe Vale
Sabell, Forrest, Cann, Sears, Harris, Raybould, Sellars, Hutchison, Armstrong, Smith, Hughes. Res: Bingham, Ward.
Saturday, May 12, 1934. Referee: J Hadlington.
Yallourn Wanderers
0 - 6 Wonthaggi Magpies

Goals: Hutton x 2, Williams x 2, Cook, P Spooner
Round One Replay
Saturday, May 19, 1934. Referee: R Hamilton.
Sunshine

Goals: Clayton x 2, R Haxby
3 - 3 Footscray Thistle
W Morton, Hughes, Fitzgerald, Shepherd, Wilson, Campbell, Hamilton, Pearson, Cunningham, J Morton, G McDonald.
Goals: Cunningham x 2, Hamilton
Monday, June 4, 1934. Middle Park. Referee: R Hamilton.
Footscray Thistle

Goals: Cunningham x 2, Lockett, Elder
4 - 2 Sunshine

Goals: H Taylor, M Haxby
Round Two
Saturday, June 16, 1934. Williamstown Road, Yarraville. Referee: H Banks.
Footscray Thistle
W Morton, Hughes, Campbell, J Morton, J Wilson, Farrow, Hamilton, Pearson, Cunningham, Elder, Lockett. Res: R Gordon, Fitzgerald.
Goals: Cunningham x 4, Hamilton x 2, J Morton, Pearson
8 - 1 Yallourn Rovers

Goal: Robertson
Saturday, June 16, 1934. Rosanna. Referee: J Wood.
Heidelberg

Goals: J Chesters x 3, Inglis x 2, Morton, Young
7 - 0 Prahran
Hall, Morse, Thomas, Hall, Bishton, Willis, Grieves, Locke, Aitken, Gaze, Morris. Res: Burton, Lanigan, Roberts, Berry.
Saturday, June 16, 1934. Coburg Oval, Coburg. Referee: J Hadlington.
Moreland
Parker, McFarlane, Johnstone, Gillon, G Semple, Jones, Friend, C Semple, Smillie, Thorpe, Cummins. Res: Hawley, Old.
Goals: Cummins x 2, Smillie
3 - 3 Preston
Croot, Smith, Macauley, Anstee, Lyons, Colgrave, Tom McCluskey, Gray, Fraser, Knowles, Francis. Res: Newman, Simpson.
Goals: Fraser x 2, Jones og
Saturday, June 16, 1934. Flinders Naval Depot, Crib Point. Referee: JB Scott.
Flinders Naval Depot

Goals: Vale x 3, Samways x 2, Gibson
6 - 1 Wonthaggi Magpies

Goal: Cook
Saturday, June 16, 1934. Middle Park. Referee: L Russell.
Royal Caledonians
Bob Morgan, George Weir, H Beats, R Gray, S Weir, Stewart, Peter Young, Norman Donald, B Gray, MacKay, Johnstone, Robb.
Goals: Johnstone x 3, MacKay x 3, Stewart x 2, B Gray, Young, S Weir
11 - 2 Savoia

Goals: Fabris, G Weir og
Saturday, June 16, 1934. Middle Park. Referee: Tommy Burns.
South Melbourne
Fenn, A Kego, W Gow, J Kego, W Muir, P O'Brien, Reid, J Cramond, F O'Brien, Wilson, Smith. Res: J Sinclair, Sketcher.
Goal: Wilson
1 - 2 Hakoah
Aguilera, Hayden, A Mackey, Marshall, Harrison, Bolton, G Hawkes, C Yaffe, Frank McIver, W Yaffe, Forrest.
Goals: Harrison, McIver
Saturday, June 16, 1934. Fawkner Park, South Yarra. Referee: A Johnston.
South Yarra
Lacey, Pickering, Ziebell, Harris, Berwick, Bailey, Johnston, Stevenson, J Baxter, Hynds, Bradd. Res: W Duff, A Duff, A Morris.
Goal: Bradd
1 - 1 St Kilda
Shepherd, Howard, Bull, J Patterson, Herbert, W Huck, Barden, Pollock, Dick, Ford, Lang. Res: Barron, Nixon, Dawson.
Goal: Herbert
Note: No record found of Melbourne Thistle's Round Two match
Round Two Replays
Saturday, June 23, 1934. Bell. Referee: J Hadlington.
Preston
Croot, Smith, Macauley, Anstee, Lyons, Colgrave, Tom McCluskey, Gray, Fraser, Knowles, Gray. Res: Simpson, Fairweather.
Goal: JG Gray
After extra time
1 - 1 Moreland
Parker, McFarlane, Johnstone, Gillon, G Semple, Jones, Friend, C Semple, Percy Lewis, Smillie, Thorpe, Cummins, Hawley, Old.
Goal: C Semple
After extra time
Saturday, June 23, 1934. Middle Park. Referee: Tommy Burns.
St Kilda
Shepherd, Howard, Bull, J Patterson, Herbert, W Huck, Barden, Pollock, Dick, Fyfe, Lang. Res: Barron, Nixon, Dawson.
0 - 2 South Yarra
Lacey, Pickering, Ziebell, Bailey, Berwick, Addie, Spetch, Stevenson, J Baxter, W Duff, Bradd. Res: Harris, Newman, Hynds.
Goals: Spetch x 2
Saturday, June 30, 1934. Olympic Park, Melbourne. Referee: J Hadlington.
Moreland
Parker, McFarlane, Johnstone, Gillon, G Semple, Jones, Friend, C Semple, Percy Lewis, Smillie, Thorpe, Cummins, Hawley, Old.
Goals: Scorers not known
Replay ordered after Moreland protested that J Lyons was a suspended player
3 - 6 Preston
Croot, Smith, Welch, Anstee, Lyons, Colgrave, Tom McCluskey, Gray, Fraser, Macauley, J Lyons, Knowles, Simpson.
Goals: J Lyons x 5, Knowles
Replay ordered after Moreland protested that J Lyons was a suspended player
Saturday, July 21, 1934. Olympic Park, Melbourne. Referee: J Hadlington.
Moreland
Parker, McFarlane, Not known, Johnstone, Not known, C Semple, Not known, Thorpe, Smillie, Cummins, Percy Lewis, Douglas, Newman.
Goals: Thorpe, Cummins, Lewis, Smillie
After extra time
4 - 4 Preston

Goals: T McCluskey x 2, Lyons, Gray
After extra time
Saturday, August 4, 1934. Middle Park. Referee: J Hadlington.
Moreland
Parker, McFarlane, Johnstone, Gillon, Jones, Howes, C Semple, Thorpe, Percy Lewis, Cummins, Friend, Old.
Goals: Lewis x 2, C Semple, Johnston, R Lyons og
5 - 3 Preston

Goals: Fraser, J Lyons, T McCluskey
Round Three
Saturday, July 7, 1934. Fawkner Park, South Yarra. Referee: Tommy Burns.
South Yarra
Lacey, Pickering, Ziebell, Bailey, Berwick, Rolands, Hamilton, Spetch, Stevenson, J Baxter, W Duff, Bradd, Addie.
Goal: Baxter
1 - 4 Royal Caledonians
Bob Morgan, George Weir, H Beats, R Gray, Andy Mayne, S Weir, Stewart, Peter Young, B Gray, Norman Donald, MacKay, Johnstone, Robb.
Goals:
Saturday, July 14, 1934. Olympic Park, Melbourne. Referee: J Wood.
Hakoah
Aguilera, W Yaffe, Leckie, J Bowman, A Roth, Harrison, G Hawkes, C Yaffe, Frank McIver, Johnny Orr, Forrest.
Goals: C Yaffe, McIver, Hawkes
3 - 0 Heidelberg
Saturday, July 21, 1934. Flinders Naval Depot, Crib Point. Referee: J Anderson.
Flinders Naval Depot

Goals: Vale, Samways, Lloyd
3 - 2 Melbourne Thistle
Turner, Calder, Hambly, Drennan, Kelly, Briggs, Treadwell, Crew, Craig, Hughes, Paulsen, Rutherford, Dracup, Hardie.
Goals: Scorers not known
Saturday, August 11, 1934. Moore Street, Coburg. Referee: J Parker.
Moreland
Parker, McFarlane, Johnstone, C Semple, Jones, Thorpe, Howes, Friend, Percy Lewis, Smillie, Cummins, Gillon, Old, Douglas.
Goals: Cummins, Smillie
2 - 1 Footscray Thistle
W Morton, Campbell, Hughes, J Morton, Peel, Farrow, Hamilton, Cunningham, Wilson, Elder, Barclay.
Goal: Cunningham
Semi-Finals
Saturday, September 1, 1934. Olympic Park, Melbourne. Referee: J Parker.
Royal Caledonians
Bob Morgan, George Weir, R Gray, Andy Mayne, S Weir, Stewart, Peter Young, B Gray, MacKay, Not known, Robb.
Goals: B Gray x 2
2 - 0 Moreland
Parker, McFarlane, Johnstone, Jones, Howes, Gillon, Friend, Currie, C Semple, Smillie, Thorpe, Cummins.
Saturday, September 1, 1934. Olympic Park, Melbourne. Referee: Tommy Burns.
Flinders Naval Depot
Bird, Ledson, Gibson, Newman, Anderson, Locke, McKay, Dorsch, Vale, Samways, Lloyd.
Goals: Dorsch, Vale
2 - 4 Hakoah
Bingham, Hayden, A Mackey, J Bowman, A Roth, Harrison, G Hawkes, C Yaffe, Frank McIver, W Yaffe, Forrest, Bolton, Marshall.
Goals: Forrest x 2, W Yaffe, McIver
1934 Dockerty Cup Final
Saturday, October 6, 1934. Olympic Park, Melbourne. Referee: J Hadlington. Sent off: R Gray, Hamilton.
Royal Caledonians
Bob Morgan, George Weir, H Beats, Andy Mayne, S Weir, Stewart, Peter Young, B Gray, Ireland, R Gray (sent off), Robb. Res: MacKay.
Goals: R Gray, B Gray, Ireland, G Weir pen
4 - 4 Hakoah
Aguilera, Hayden, A Mackey, J Bowman, A Roth, Harrison (sent off), G Hawkes, C Yaffe, W Yaffe, Frank McIver, Forrest, Bolton.
Goals: C Yaffe, McIver x 2, S Weir og
1934 Dockerty Cup Final Replay
Saturday, October 13, 1934. Olympic Park, Melbourne. Referee: J Hadlington.
Royal Caledonians
Bob Morgan, George Weir, H Beats, Andy Mayne, S Weir, Stewart, Peter Young, B Gray, R Gray, Johnstone, Robb, Ireland, MacKay.
Goals: Robb, R Gray x 2
3 - 2 Hakoah
Aguilera, Hayden, A Mackey, J Bowman, A Roth, G Hawkes, C Yaffe, W Yaffe, Frank McIver, Forrest, Johnnie Orr, Bolton.
Goals: Forrest x 2