NSW - 1898 Gardiner Cup Results

1898 Gardiner Cup Results

The Gardiner Cup results were researched and compiled by John Punshon and written by Greg Stock.

Source various New South Wales newspapers.

FIRST ROUND
Knockout Format
Adamstown, Balmain Working Men's Institute, Joadja, Pyrmont Rovers, West Newcastle - Bye

Home Team v Away Team
Saturday June 4 1898
Sydney University Oval

Pyrmont Rangers
Lineup Included; A.Hotson, G.Hotson, A.Inglis, W.Mills, J.Hatton, C.Harrison.
Goals: A.Hotson, G.Hotson (x2), A.Inglis (x2), W.Mills, J.Hatton, C.Harrison 8 - 0 Granville
(Lineup Not Known)
Saturday June 4 1898
Wentworth Park, Glebe
Referee: David Gunn

Pyrmont Volunteers
Lineup Included; Hook, Sid Watson, F.Davis, B.Shaw, Vassella, J.Trenholm, Charlie White, J.Carey, Will Banner.
Goals: Trenholm (x3), White (x2), Carey, Banner 7 - 2 Balmain
Lineup Included; Logan, J.Gibson, A.Tomb, C.Thorburn, Andy Ferguson, Holt, W.McCulloch, Phillips, G.Day.
Goals: Ferguson, Day
Saturday June 4 1898
West Wallsend
Referee: R.Scott

West Wallsend
(Lineup Not Known)
Goals: (Goalscorers Not Known) 2 - 3 Balgownie Rangers
(Lineup Not Known)
Goals: (Goalscorers Not Known)

SECOND ROUND

Saturday June 25 1898
Sydney University Oval
Referee: James McCreadie

Pyrmont Rangers
A.Parr, Jack Wilson, G.Hotson, Hatton, Mills, Stewart, McDougall, C.Harrison, Keogh, T.Hotson, A.Hotson.
Goal: T.Hotson 1 - 8 Volunteer
T.Hook, R.Martin, Arthur Banner, F.Davis, Vassella, Sid Watson, J.Trenholm, B.Shaw, Charlie White, J.Carey, Will Banner.
Goals: Carey (x3), Shaw (x2), White (x2), Trenholm
Saturday June 25 1898
Adamstown
Referee: E.Lyons

Adamstown
Lineup Included; Harris, James Harrison, E.Bartley, M.Bartley, Gillard, Chapman.
Goals: Harrison, Chapman 2 - 2 West Newcastle
Lineup Included; A.Bailey, J.Miller, Sandy Jackson, W.Harrison.
Goals: Harrison, Miller pen
Saturday June 25 1898
Balgownie Rangers won on forfeit

Balgownie Rangers
Won on Forfeit W - L Balmain Working Men's Institute
Lost on Forfeit

SECOND ROUND REPLAY

Saturday July 16 1898
Newcastle Cricket Ground
Referee: William McPherson

West Newcastle
Lineup Included; A.Bailey, Sandy Jackson, T.Harrison, J.Hamilton, Stirling, Dave Jackson.
Goals: Harrison, Hamilton, Stirling 3 - 1 Adamstown
Lineup Included; E.Bartley, J.Brown, M.Bartley.
Goal: (Goalscorer Not Known)

SEMI-FINALS

Saturday July 23 1898
Sydney University Oval
Referee: John Logan

Balgownie Rangers
C.Campbell, York, Taylor, Davis, Thompson, P.Hunter, Brown, Figtree, Fitzgibbon, Green, R.Campbell.
Goals: Brown, Fitzgibbon 2 - 3 West Newcastle
A.Bailey, Sandy Jackson, Dave Jackson, J.Syms, W.Harrison, R.Brooks, H.Humphries, J.Armstrong, J.Harrison, T.Harrison, T.Hamilton.
Goals: Humphries, Hamilton, J.Harrison
Saturday July 23 1898
Sydney University Oval
Referee: David Gunn

Volunteer
T.Hook, Arthur Banner, R.Martin, F.Davis, Vassella, Will Banner, J.Trenholm, B.Shaw, Charlie White, J.Carey, Hargreaves.
Goals: Trenholm, Shaw (x2), White 4 - 1 Pyrmont Rovers
Stevens, Morrison, B.Southward, Middleton, Train, H.Fox, Brown, H.Morrison, Lougher, A.Herron, Herron.
Goal: Herron

1898 GARDINER CUP FINAL

Saturday September 24 1898
Royal Agricultural Ground, Sydney

Volunteer
T.Hook, R.Martin, Arthur Banner, J.Train, Sid Watson, F.David, B.Shaw, J.Trenholm, Charlie White, J.Carey, Will Banner.
Goals: White, Trenholm, Other Goalscorer Not Known 3 - 2 West Newcastle
A.Bailey, Sandy Jackson, J.Miller, W.Harrison, J.Syms, Dave Jackson, Joblin, H.Humphries, J.Harrison, T.Harrison, H.Moore.
Goals: Humphries (x2)

FIRST ROUND Knockout Format Adamstown, Balmain Working Men's Institute, Joadja, Pyrmont Rovers, West Newcastle - Bye
Home Team		v		Away Team
Saturday June 4 1898 Sydney University Oval
Pyrmont Rangers Lineup Included; A.Hotson, G.Hotson, A.Inglis, W.Mills, J.Hatton, C.Harrison. Goals: A.Hotson, G.Hotson (x2), A.Inglis (x2), W.Mills, J.Hatton, C.Harrison	8	-	0	Granville (Lineup Not Known)
Saturday June 4 1898 Wentworth Park, Glebe Referee: David Gunn
Pyrmont Volunteers Lineup Included; Hook, Sid Watson, F.Davis, B.Shaw, Vassella, J.Trenholm, Charlie White, J.Carey, Will Banner. Goals: Trenholm (x3), White (x2), Carey, Banner	7	-	2	Balmain Lineup Included; Logan, J.Gibson, A.Tomb, C.Thorburn, Andy Ferguson, Holt, W.McCulloch, Phillips, G.Day. Goals: Ferguson, Day
Saturday June 4 1898 West Wallsend Referee: R.Scott
West Wallsend (Lineup Not Known) Goals: (Goalscorers Not Known)	2	-	3	Balgownie Rangers (Lineup Not Known) Goals: (Goalscorers Not Known)

SECOND ROUND

Saturday June 25 1898 Sydney University Oval Referee: James McCreadie
Pyrmont Rangers A.Parr, Jack Wilson, G.Hotson, Hatton, Mills, Stewart, McDougall, C.Harrison, Keogh, T.Hotson, A.Hotson. Goal: T.Hotson	1	-	8	Volunteer T.Hook, R.Martin, Arthur Banner, F.Davis, Vassella, Sid Watson, J.Trenholm, B.Shaw, Charlie White, J.Carey, Will Banner. Goals: Carey (x3), Shaw (x2), White (x2), Trenholm
Saturday June 25 1898 Adamstown Referee: E.Lyons
Adamstown Lineup Included; Harris, James Harrison, E.Bartley, M.Bartley, Gillard, Chapman. Goals: Harrison, Chapman	2	-	2	West Newcastle Lineup Included; A.Bailey, J.Miller, Sandy Jackson, W.Harrison. Goals: Harrison, Miller pen
Saturday June 25 1898 Balgownie Rangers won on forfeit
Balgownie Rangers Won on Forfeit	W	-	L	Balmain Working Men's Institute Lost on Forfeit

SECOND ROUND REPLAY
Saturday July 16 1898 Newcastle Cricket Ground Referee: William McPherson
West Newcastle Lineup Included; A.Bailey, Sandy Jackson, T.Harrison, J.Hamilton, Stirling, Dave Jackson. Goals: Harrison, Hamilton, Stirling	3	-	1	Adamstown Lineup Included; E.Bartley, J.Brown, M.Bartley. Goal: (Goalscorer Not Known)

SEMI-FINALS
Saturday July 23 1898 Sydney University Oval Referee: John Logan
Balgownie Rangers C.Campbell, York, Taylor, Davis, Thompson, P.Hunter, Brown, Figtree, Fitzgibbon, Green, R.Campbell. Goals: Brown, Fitzgibbon	2	-	3	West Newcastle A.Bailey, Sandy Jackson, Dave Jackson, J.Syms, W.Harrison, R.Brooks, H.Humphries, J.Armstrong, J.Harrison, T.Harrison, T.Hamilton. Goals: Humphries, Hamilton, J.Harrison
Saturday July 23 1898 Sydney University Oval Referee: David Gunn
Volunteer T.Hook, Arthur Banner, R.Martin, F.Davis, Vassella, Will Banner, J.Trenholm, B.Shaw, Charlie White, J.Carey, Hargreaves. Goals: Trenholm, Shaw (x2), White	4	-	1	Pyrmont Rovers Stevens, Morrison, B.Southward, Middleton, Train, H.Fox, Brown, H.Morrison, Lougher, A.Herron, Herron. Goal: Herron

1898 GARDINER CUP FINAL
Saturday September 24 1898 Royal Agricultural Ground, Sydney
Volunteer T.Hook, R.Martin, Arthur Banner, J.Train, Sid Watson, F.David, B.Shaw, J.Trenholm, Charlie White, J.Carey, Will Banner. Goals: White, Trenholm, Other Goalscorer Not Known	3	-	2	West Newcastle A.Bailey, Sandy Jackson, J.Miller, W.Harrison, J.Syms, Dave Jackson, Joblin, H.Humphries, J.Harrison, T.Harrison, H.Moore. Goals: Humphries (x2)